6 February 2012, 14:29
"There is no masterplan", + Warn added for 'Paranoia'
| MacIntosh |
|
Russia

Vladimir Putin
Prime Minister of the Russian Federation

|
Alright, let's talk about this issue here.. because from the perspective of a player and not an av .. I can tell you there is a very real and clear bias on the part of certain avs in this game, in the way issues are addressed between players and avs over real and factual concerns about results and a clear "pick and choose' aspect for certain things, the most recent one being Iran attacked by Russia and the United States after India deploys 64 S300 systems for the protection of Iran, now sure, maybe India gave the order not to protect Iran, but that major part of policy should have been made public in the article, "Indian AA systems refuse to protect Iran from American/Russian bombings" or something like that, with some political effects for both nations, you don't send an extremely large amount of anti-air systems only to give an order not to use them for what their intentions are.
What im asking for is consistency, which is very very lacking.
--------------------
 “Reason over passion.” - Pierre Elliot Trudeau
Member of the 'Order of Strathclyde' Round 14 Awards(United States): "Best Military Orders" Round 15 Awards (Iran/Pakistan): "Most Militarily-Successful Player" Round 16 Awards (France): Round 17 Awards (Syria): "Most Liked Character" - "Most Military Successful Player" - "Most Original Player" - "Most Liked Character" -"Best Miltary Orders" Round 18 Awards (Head Avatar):
|
|
|
| Driver |
|
Unregistered

|
I just got warned for it too.
What I do want to say is: I and many other players have noticed a bias the entire round and I'm even hearing from players that they've spent a good deal of their time just fighting that bias instead of just actual playing. The details of this are likely very well known as I haven't kept them secret when I left as a player.
I still believe it exists and there's a difference between me playing because I like this round and because I find it important not to leave the USA hanging on 1 player.
This post has been edited by Driver on 6 February 2010, 17:57
|
|
|
| John McCloud2 |
|

The Chosen One
IPOL Avatar

|
Why are none of my Pakistan actions being touched. My Budget, My national speech and actions. or my one DPOL? I try to politely ask the avs for status and i either get a no answer or they are working on it.
*awaits the warn*
--------------------
Democracy means listening to as many voices as possible. Not A select few...
Democracy means letting the people decide their fate. Not the leadership dictating the Agenda.
|
|
|
| Hadrianus |
|
Blake Roberts
Magister Militum

|
If you look at the actions you've sent in, you'll notice that there are a massive number. Between Wednesday and Friday, fifty actions were sent in. Probably twenty more by today. I assume they're working on a triage basis.
--------------------
Your Military and Intelligence Avatar for Round 18 Countries Played: Afghanistan, Taliban, Iraq, Cote d'Ivoire, Egypt, United States, Ukraine, Mahdi Army.
|
|
|
| John McCloud2 |
|

The Chosen One
IPOL Avatar

|
Then if that is the case the avs need to put a temp pause on the round to fix the back log or get more avs to work on the backlog.
--------------------
Democracy means listening to as many voices as possible. Not A select few...
Democracy means letting the people decide their fate. Not the leadership dictating the Agenda.
|
|
|
| Ivanhoe |
|
United Kingdom

David Cameron
Prime Minister

|
During this round I've been labeled many things by many different players. That's inevitable, because in a game based on judgment, players will always insist it is the avatars judgment that is flawed and not their own. There is no bias what-so-ever, I simply process orders, and try to do so as coherently and accurately as possible - as does every other avatar.
I expected things like this to happen when I ran, and I always said I would give everyone their right to free speech (or free posting rather), whether the bounds of sanity. I also know I'm a big enough personality to take these criticisms, which is why this round is still running, and will still be running for many IG years to come.
--------------------
 "Tell me how many people could have been convicted for squeezing a girl's arse, nearly every guy could be up for that." -A guy from N-Dubz (quoted for truth)
|
|
|
| John McCloud2 |
|

The Chosen One
IPOL Avatar

|
Then if things stay the way that they are... You will start to see people leave SPC for other nation/political sims or leave all together.
--------------------
Democracy means listening to as many voices as possible. Not A select few...
Democracy means letting the people decide their fate. Not the leadership dictating the Agenda.
|
|
|
| Ivanhoe |
|
United Kingdom

David Cameron
Prime Minister

|
| QUOTE (John McCloud2 @ 6 February 2010, 18:05) | | Then if things stay the way that they are... You will start to see people leave SPC for other nation/political sims or leave all together. |
By all means, leave.
I expect I'll see you again at the end of the week with another alt account. Perhaps this time it will be called "NOT-NUSIL".
--------------------
 "Tell me how many people could have been convicted for squeezing a girl's arse, nearly every guy could be up for that." -A guy from N-Dubz (quoted for truth)
|
|
|
| Hadrianus |
|
Blake Roberts
Magister Militum

|
| QUOTE (John McCloud2 @ 6 February 2010, 18:05) | | Then if things stay the way that they are... You will start to see people leave SPC for other nation/political sims or leave all together. |
This game has never survived a round with a conflict of anywhere near the magnitude we have seen, it's hard to manage it and things will go wrong sometimes but I'm pleased it has kept going.
What I'm trying to see is what bias or master plan is going on. Two days ago it was favor towards Iran because they managed to invade Israel, three days ago it was favor to Israel by smashing everyone, and now it's stacked against Iran with the American attack? I don't see a coherent conspiracy. Each side has suffered their ups and downs.
--------------------
Your Military and Intelligence Avatar for Round 18 Countries Played: Afghanistan, Taliban, Iraq, Cote d'Ivoire, Egypt, United States, Ukraine, Mahdi Army.
|
|
|
| Ivanhoe |
|
United Kingdom

David Cameron
Prime Minister

|
I also believe that a man of such supposed incompetence as myself would be incapable of maintaining this machiavellian conspiracy, that appears to have no purpose, direction or end. I seem to be an avatar with many paradoxical traits.
--------------------
 "Tell me how many people could have been convicted for squeezing a girl's arse, nearly every guy could be up for that." -A guy from N-Dubz (quoted for truth)
|
|
|
| General Valkanov |
|


|
| QUOTE (Ivanhoe @ 6 February 2010, 18:14) | | I also believe that a man of such supposed incompetence as myself would be incapable of maintaining this machiavellian conspiracy, that appears to have no purpose, direction or end. I seem to be an avatar with many paradoxical traits. |
Well dude like I said you are in the position of God. And when it doesnt turn the way people want it they say that God is responsible for that.
--------------------
History is a set of lies agreed upon.Napoleon BonaparteIf you wish to be a success in the world, promise everything, deliver nothing.Napoleon BonaparteReligion is what keeps the poor from murdering the rich.Napoleon BonaparteI am a BULGARIAN!! 
|
|
|
| Ivanhoe |
|
United Kingdom

David Cameron
Prime Minister

|
Maybe I am, perhaps that's what everything is building up to in SPC. First the Armageddon (ME war) and then the second coming, where I shall descend from the Admin CP, remove you all from your nations and declare myself sole-ruler of planet earth (IG not IRL).
--------------------
 "Tell me how many people could have been convicted for squeezing a girl's arse, nearly every guy could be up for that." -A guy from N-Dubz (quoted for truth)
|
|
|
| merlins |
|
Ukraine

Viktor Yanukovych
President of Ukraine

|
As for the round - it is very interesting to follow all the developments and at some point it is possible to make some mistakes or to forget things, but the Middle East war with all its aspects, as far as I can tell, felt real and unbiased.
As for anything within a war - if anything would go according to ones plans and strategies, both sides would actually win - and that's impossible.
I don't know, if it is just me and because I am stupid or something, but I don't see this all-over bias in the game anymore as in previous rounds. Everything appears to be well considered and with the pros and cons.
--------------------
Round 14 (Latvia) Awards: Best DPOL Orders; Most Improved Player Round 15 (Germany) Awards: Most Economically-Successful Player; Best Diplomat; Most Trusting Player Round 16 (Poland) Awards: Most Environmentally-Friendly Player; Best DPOL Orders Round 17 (People's Republic of China) Awards: Most Accomplished Player, Most Economically-Successful Player, Most Intellectual Player, Best DPOL Orders, Best National Newspaper Round 18 (Ukraine)
|
|
|
| Driver |
|
Unregistered

|
| QUOTE (merlins @ 6 February 2010, 18:27) | As for the round - it is very interesting to follow all the developments and at some point it is possible to make some mistakes or to forget things, but the Middle East war with all its aspects, as far as I can tell, felt real and unbiased.
As for anything within a war - if anything would go according to ones plans and strategies, both sides would actually win - and that's impossible.
I don't know, if it is just me and because I am stupid or something, but I don't see this all-over bias in the game anymore as in previous rounds. Everything appears to be well considered and with the pros and cons. |
Well youre right that you dont win ever war or mission or whatever, you win some you lose some. My foundation for the whole master plan hypothesis is that entire actions and their results go missing (read: ignored). Behind the scenes Im constantly hearing other players complain about these things; often they don't want to get involved in any flame wars that for example led to me leaving the country I was playing at the time. There are multiple ex-avs in there as well who only add to my view of this.
I am fully aware that I'm complaining while I myself am not at the helm and it's increadibly easy to critisize others when youre just on the sidelines and out of the crosshairs, but from what other players tell me, from what I experience myself, from what I hear why ex-avs became just that: EX avs, I know this isn't just another round.
It has its benifits, I'll give you that, normal rounds wouldnt survive this war we've just had.
|
|
|
| Ivanhoe |
|
United Kingdom

David Cameron
Prime Minister

|
If anyone wants to come out with any specific accusations please do so. As has been witnessed by Drivers appointment as second player of the most powerful nation in the game, I won't hold it against you.
--------------------
 "Tell me how many people could have been convicted for squeezing a girl's arse, nearly every guy could be up for that." -A guy from N-Dubz (quoted for truth)
|
|
|
| John McCloud2 |
|

The Chosen One
IPOL Avatar

|
If you are the second coming of God and following the Armageddon in the Bible..... You needed to have a big battle between the forces of Good and Evil in Megiddo Israel. That is where "the final battle" was foretold in Prophecy.
I am not going to leave SPC voluntarily, so if anyone has any issues with me...... I am going to have to be site banned.
--------------------
Democracy means listening to as many voices as possible. Not A select few...
Democracy means letting the people decide their fate. Not the leadership dictating the Agenda.
|
|
|
| Ivanhoe |
|
United Kingdom

David Cameron
Prime Minister

|
| QUOTE (John McCloud2 @ 6 February 2010, 20:13) | If you are the second coming of God and following the Armageddon in the Bible..... You needed to have a big battle between the forces of Good and Evil in Megiddo Israel. That is where "the final battle" was foretold in Prophecy.
I am not going to leave SPC voluntarily, so if anyone has any issues with me...... I am going to have to be site banned. |
LOL! Your like Mel Gibson in that South Park episode.  You can torture me all you want, I still won't tell you!"
--------------------
 "Tell me how many people could have been convicted for squeezing a girl's arse, nearly every guy could be up for that." -A guy from N-Dubz (quoted for truth)
|
|
|
| General Valkanov |
|


|
| QUOTE (Ivanhoe @ 6 February 2010, 20:19) | LOL!
Your like Mel Gibson in that South Park episode.

You can torture me all you want, I still won't tell you!" |
"Oooh My nipples are so hard."
--------------------
History is a set of lies agreed upon.Napoleon BonaparteIf you wish to be a success in the world, promise everything, deliver nothing.Napoleon BonaparteReligion is what keeps the poor from murdering the rich.Napoleon BonaparteI am a BULGARIAN!! 
|
|
|
| lardbeetle |
|
China

Hu Jintao
President of the People's Republic of China

|
| QUOTE (MacIntosh @ 6 February 2010, 17:47) | Alright, let's talk about this issue here.. because from the perspective of a player and not an av .. I can tell you there is a very real and clear bias on the part of certain avs in this game, in the way issues are addressed between players and avs over real and factual concerns about results and a clear "pick and choose' aspect for certain things, the most recent one being Iran attacked by Russia and the United States after India deploys 64 S300 systems for the protection of Iran, now sure, maybe India gave the order not to protect Iran, but that major part of policy should have been made public in the article, "Indian AA systems refuse to protect Iran from American/Russian bombings" or something like that, with some political effects for both nations, you don't send an extremely large amount of anti-air systems only to give an order not to use them for what their intentions are.
What im asking for is consistency, which is very very lacking. |
Well, the whole purpose of the system was an ABM shield. It should have been evident in the original article that I had given orders to ignore ANY aircraft unless it was known that they were carrying nuclear weapons (or the SAM sites were under attack).
--------------------
 Veni, vidi, vici. ~ Julius Caesar. (Attributed to) Awards: Best New Player (Round 17)
|
|
|
| General Valkanov |
|


|
| QUOTE (lardbeetle @ 6 February 2010, 21:50) | | Well, the whole purpose of the system was an ABM shield. It should have been evident in the original article that I had given orders to ignore ANY aircraft unless it was known that they were carrying nuclear weapons (or the SAM sites were under attack). |
That awnsers the issue well.
--------------------
History is a set of lies agreed upon.Napoleon BonaparteIf you wish to be a success in the world, promise everything, deliver nothing.Napoleon BonaparteReligion is what keeps the poor from murdering the rich.Napoleon BonaparteI am a BULGARIAN!! 
|
|
|
| Vespasian |
|
Unregistered

|
I am new here, so I dont know if my words carry any weight, but here's my two cents. I will say that I have sent 2 actions since beginning, both were read, one was put into stone. I have yet to see anything about Dutch Patriot systems in the middle east being put on high alert in the World Broadcast. The article that I wrote and sent with the action, so that the avs could just slap it up with minimal editing still has not been added. There is little point now as the conflict is over. I have nothing against any player here, or Ivanhoe or any av. I just assumed that it was because the war would bring in a flood of action and some things are bound to be overlooked, which I think is what happened. I was just curious why it was read, but not posted, but whatever. What has happened, happened. I'll still play this game, It is very interesting. I was very surprised when I read that a war like this would have caused huge problems with other rounds, but I thought it went off quite well. I guess the old saying "Shit happens" has a place here.
|
|
|
| thedude72 |
|
Spain

His Majesy Juan Carlos I
King of Spain

|
That and I'm fairly sure that an S300 wouldn't be able to get a lock on an F-22 or SU-39 anyway. They're some of the best planes ever made. Maybe it could- I don't know that much about SAMs and the like- but I doubt it
--------------------
Round 17: Spain 
|
|
|
| lardbeetle |
|
China

Hu Jintao
President of the People's Republic of China

|
| QUOTE (thedude72 @ 6 February 2010, 22:11) | | That and I'm fairly sure that an S300 wouldn't be able to get a lock on an F-22 or SU-39 anyway. They're some of the best planes ever made. Maybe it could- I don't know that much about SAMs and the like- but I doubt it |
Neither of those were being used. My missiles could have probably shot down half of the US and Russian strike forces... but India attacking US and Russian planes would have been f%$^ing crazy...
--------------------
 Veni, vidi, vici. ~ Julius Caesar. (Attributed to) Awards: Best New Player (Round 17)
|
|
|
| General Valkanov |
|


|
| QUOTE (thedude72 @ 6 February 2010, 22:11) | | That and I'm fairly sure that an S300 wouldn't be able to get a lock on an F-22 or SU-39 anyway. They're some of the best planes ever made. Maybe it could- I don't know that much about SAMs and the like- but I doubt it |
They are still not widely used by both militaries. Especially the F-22. Dont know about the SU-29.
--------------------
History is a set of lies agreed upon.Napoleon BonaparteIf you wish to be a success in the world, promise everything, deliver nothing.Napoleon BonaparteReligion is what keeps the poor from murdering the rich.Napoleon BonaparteI am a BULGARIAN!! 
|
|
|
| Jos1311 |
|

Thor
the most powerful av

|
I can say that I try to look at actions as objective as I can and that the majority of the avs try this, this is however difficult and nearly impossible as everyone has a bias when it comes to a few subjects.
As for the statements about a master plan, I can state nothing more than this is not at all true. It is difficult to process all the actions that enter this game and for the sake of the game, some less important things might be forgotten or not posted at all. Let's take (for instance) the Netherlands placing all units on high alert and sending another action for doing the same with the patriot systems in Afghanistan. I for one believe that one single article is enough. I made a note in the ISAF forum that all patriots were on high alert as well. I however believe it is not necessary to make an article for every thing. If players want this, perhaps they should start adding more articles themselves.....
We are trying to run this show as good as we can and try our best to process as many actions as possible, but we do make errors and we too are only human. However I must state my extreme disappointment with the way people are handling this, instead of recognizing that we as avs might be very busy and we too can make mistakes due to this, people only seem to be criticizing us for things being done wrong.
People, this is a game and if you can all do this so much better, perhaps you should give up your nation and become an av. I would have preferred to play a nation, however I volunteered to let you all play this game. Yet all I (and I think all other avs as well) get in return is people complaining and falling over even the smallest things. This is not at all motivating and perhaps this has been one of the reasons why we have seen so many avs leave.
--------------------
Nations played: The Netherlands, Czech Republic, India, Brazil, Ukraine, PRC, Russia, Norway, Indonesia, Germany and South Korea. HERO OF SPC RESTART (ROUND 12) as well as an avatar during several rounds.
|
|
|
| King Krug |
|
Unregistered

|
Since I have not much to do, I offer to help with anything any Mod needs. I have played a few sim games in the past, Qpawn only. But I offer to help. I do not want to see this game die off. Most of my stuff hasn't been processed either but its probably cause I am not very good at running my nation/guy. Ciao, Garak
|
|
|
| Ivanhoe |
|
United Kingdom

David Cameron
Prime Minister

|
This game has never been in a healthier position, contrary to some claims.
1) We have a good team of avatars, who are only being strained so much because of high player activity.
2) The round has survived a war that would have normally resulted in complete IC and OOC anarchy with a round restart.
3) Even people who complain all the time can't resist playing.
SPC is doing just fine, and I'm sure players will have even more fun as the round progresses and they get to see some of their long-term projects come to fruition.
--------------------
 "Tell me how many people could have been convicted for squeezing a girl's arse, nearly every guy could be up for that." -A guy from N-Dubz (quoted for truth)
|
|
|
Track this topic
Receive email notification when a reply has been made to this topic and you are not active on the board.
Subscribe to this forum
Receive email notification when a new topic is posted in this forum and you are not active on the board.
Download / Print this Topic
Download this topic in different formats or view a printer friendly version.
[ Script Execution time: 0.1307 ] [ 11 queries used ] [ GZIP Enabled ]
|